Last weekend's Annapolis Symphony
Orchestra concert, intriguingly titled "Bittersweet Beauty,"
presented the Annapolis listening audience with an
attractively diverse selection of music represented by
composers from four countries. Within the course of its
90-minute concert, the ASO - under Music Director Jose-Luis
Novo - managed to tantalize its audience, make it laugh and
make it cry, before subjecting it to a stretch of utter
boredom.
The
"tantalize" was courtesy of young Thai composer Narong
Prangcharoen, whose evocative work, "Tri-Sattawat," received
its world premiere at the concerts. This short piece adeptly
combines the tonal attributes of a Western symphony orchestra
with the sounds of traditional Asian music, including an array
of authentic Thai percussion instruments, complete with gongs,
bells and the like. Beginning with very high notes on the
bassoon, the music gradually unfolds like the petals of an
exotic flower until the entire orchestra picks up the
fragments of sound and weaves them into a varied tapestry that
challenges the ear with its many melodic threads.
For such a delicately crafted piece, there were
surprisingly strong brass and percussion undertones, and these
served to accentuate the intricacy of the music played by the
strings. One could pick up little touches that resembled the
work of other composers (I heard Stravinsky, Ligeti and
Maurice Jarre in its enticing and unusual sounds - but my ears
are strange anyway), yet the aggregate impression of the work
was emphatically an individualistic expression of celebration
by a composer who definitely has something to say in his
music.
The "laughter" was ably provided by that most comedic of
opera composers, Gioacchino Rossini. His overture to the opera
"La Scala di Seta" under the sure direction by Mr. Novo was
like the foam on top of a cup of cappuccino - sweet, frothy
and containing no real substance, but something you'd
assuredly miss if it weren't there.
The key to the performance was the crisp articulation by
the strings. This is an attribute of the ASO I've commented on
before, and just as it was critical in establishing the mood
of Shostakovich's 10th Symphony last season, the precision in
the playing lets all of Rossini's comedic genius shine:
Nothing is blurred nor sounds hurried, and that's how the
music should go. I took particular note of the wonderfully
controlled crescendo that Mr. Novo built during the piece, as
this enhanced the charm of this lustrous performance.
The "tears" of the concert were represented by Sir Edward
Elgar's elegiac Cello Concerto with highly acclaimed soloist
Julie Albers. I've been making a mental list of "Things the
Annapolis Symphony Does Really, Really Well" (incidentally,
the list keeps growing longer), and one of the entries is
"provides beautiful and collaborative accompaniments to good
soloists."
I have frequently noted just how able an orchestral
accompanist Mr. Novo is: There are conductors who view the
soloist as little more than an intruder in the orchestra's
sonic domain, just as there are conductors who subordinate the
orchestra to the soloist to the point that you think you're
listening to a solo performance minus orchestra. Mr. Novo
takes neither approach. He and his soloists clearly understand
that the composer intended the concerto as a collaborative
undertaking, and that while the solo instrument takes center
stage, it must work its musical magic against a strongly
profiled background of discernible orchestral playing.
This approach worked magnificently in the ASO's performance
of the Elgar concerto, but what made it special was the
illustrious character of Ms. Albers' solo work. Unlike
Jacqueline du Pre, who helped put this concerto on the musical
map with her highly emotional, "take-no-prisoners" approach,
Ms. Albers illuminates a more restrained side to Elgar's
music. Although her statements of the initial elegy in the
first movement and rollicking rondo theme in the fourth are as
emphatic as any I have heard, she also knows when to employ a
more delicate tone, as in the lament in the third movement.
It's like she is softly inviting the listener to enter Elgar's
private thoughts and share his sorrows introspectively.
Ms. Albers possesses a subtle mastery of her instrument
that is a joy to hear. She may be a lower profile cellist than
some others on the scene today, but this allows the listener
to concentrate on the felicities of the music rather than be
dazzled by the performer's technique. As she demonstrated in
the Elgar, she can, however, assert herself when a defiant and
strongly etched phrase is needed. Most impressive.
In previous reviews I've commended Mr. Novo for his
tendency to perform symphonic works "straight," with few
mannerisms or eccentricities in interpretation. That approach
worked well with such magnificent compositions as the
Shostakovich 10th or Sibelius' Second Symphony. Unfortunately,
in an uneven work like the Schumann Symphony No. 4 (arguably
Schumann's weakest symphony), it didn't work well at all.
Robert Schumann's symphonic work is very problematic. He
was a master of small lyrical themes, and this mastery shows
to its best advantage in his piano music and his songs. But in
the Fourth Symphony, the listener is left with a few lovely
melodies that are never developed in symphonic fashion: The
composer either repeats them several times with little or no
variation, or simply drops them and moves on to something
else.
The best parts of the ASO's reading of the symphony were
the first and fourth movements. In them, Mr. Novo aptly
highlighted Schumann's undeniable feeling for melody and
directness of expression. The two middle movements, however,
were turgid and prosaic, with the ASO exhibiting a nice sense
of structure, but little else.
So give the ASO a batting average of .750 (excuse the
baseball analogy, but spring training is here), a very
laudable one, particularly considering the striking variety of
music performed. The eclectic nature of this concert was well
within the realm of what Annapolis audiences have come to
expect from the ASO and serves as a very positive response to
those jaded listeners who wearily complain that classical
orchestras only play the same music over and over again. In
fact, if one reviews the ASO programs of the past two seasons,
one finds an attractive variety of works - both the familiar
and the unusual - to appeal to the musical taste of the most
discerning musical connoisseur.
And so I say to Mr. Novo, in the spirit of that great
musical commentator Oliver Twist, "Please, Sir - I want some
more."
David Lindauer, a lifelong student of music, reviews
classical music for The Capital.